What to Ask During a Consultation Before Hiring a Criminal Defense Attorney

Zach Baber • June 6, 2025

When you’re facing criminal charges, choosing the right defense attorney is one of the most important decisions you’ll make.

Whether you're in Columbia City, Warsaw, Albion, or Huntington, Indiana, your attorney will be the person guiding you through court, protecting your rights, and helping you move forward.

But how do you know who the right attorney is?

Most defense lawyers offer consultations, and that meeting isn’t just for the attorney to learn about your case.

The consultation is your chance to ask smart questions and make sure the person you’re hiring is experienced, responsive, and trustworthy.

Here are some of the most important questions to ask during a criminal defense consultation:

1. Have You Handled Cases Like Mine Before?

Experience matters, especially in criminal defense.

Ask if the attorney has represented clients facing similar charges (e.g., OWI, theft, drug possession, domestic battery).

A lawyer who’s familiar with your type of case will know what to expect and how to defend it effectively.

Tip: Ask how those past cases turned out and what the biggest challenges were. Attorneys won't be able to divulge attorney/client privilege, but they should be able to tell you what to expect in that county by using past cases as guidance.

2. What’s Your Experience in This County?

Every county in Indiana has its own way of doing things.

Ask if the attorney has experience practicing in the local courts, and whether they’ve worked with the judge or prosecutor assigned to your case.

In places like Whitley County, Kosciusko County, or Noble County, familiarity with local procedures and people can make a difference in how your case is handled.

3. What’s Your Communication Style?

You want an attorney who will keep you informed.

Ask:

How often will I get updates?
Will I hear from you directly or from your staff?
How quickly do you respond to emails or calls?

4. What Are the Possible Outcomes in My Case?

A good attorney won’t make promises, but they should give you a realistic picture of:

Best-case scenario
Worst-case scenario
Most likely outcomes based on local practices

This helps you set expectations and plan ahead.

5. What Happens Next?

If you decide to hire the attorney, ask them to walk you through the next steps:

Will you go to court with me?
What paperwork is needed?
What’s your timeline for building the defense?

Knowing what to expect reduces stress and shows you how prepared the attorney really is.

6. What Are Your Fees?

Always ask how the attorney charges and what that fee includes.

Is it a flat fee, hourly, or retainer?

Does it include trial representation?

Are payment plans available?

Final Thoughts: Don’t Be Afraid to Ask Questions

This is your future. Your freedom. Your name.

We always tell our potential clients during the consultation that this is a two-way interview.

You deserve an attorney who takes your case seriously and treats you with respect.

Asking the right questions during your consultation helps you make a confident, informed decision.

At Baber & Baber, we believe every client should feel heard and supported from day one.

Whether you're in Columbia City, Warsaw, Albion, or anywhere in Northeast Indiana, make sure you hire someone who’s ready to fight for you and walk with you.

📍 Need criminal defense in Whitley County or surrounding areas?
Baber & Baber, P.C. is based in Columbia City and proudly serves Northeast Indiana.

This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

< Older Post Newer Post >